Connect with us

Editorials

‘I Still Know What You Did Last Summer’: A Lesson in How to Watch a Stupid Movie

Published

on

If you made a word cloud out of every review of 1998’s I Still Know What You Did Last Summer from across Rotten Tomatoes (7%), IMDb (4.7/10), Letterboxd (2.4/5), and Metacritic (21/100), it would basically spit out a blank sheet of paper with the word “STUPID” written across it in 182 point font and maybe a small “Jennifer Love Hewitt” somewhere in the corner.

I Know What Stupid Thing You Did Last Summer

To be fair, the film – the first sequel to the 1997 post-Scream slasher I Know What You Did Last Summer – comes by its reputation honestly. It follows Final Girl Julie James (Hewitt) and her new college friends (Brandy, Mekhi Phifer, some white guy) to an off-season resort in the Bahamas on a summer vacation that the girls won in a radio contest where they got the capital of Brazil incorrect (a fact that becomes a clue to the shady nature of the trip, but not until over an hour later).

While Julie is busy being stalked by a hook-wielding killer for the second time in as many years, the film presents viewers with a fantasia on the theme of stupid. This includes a threat-via-karaoke-machine, the reveal that the guy who goes by the name “Benson” is (you guessed it) Ben’s son, and a very early performance from Jack Black in a bad wig (in the sense that he has locks and also they’re terrible).

Hell, the title’s not even correct. The event that the killer is getting revenge for actually happened two summers ago.

A Flawed Yet Fascinating Slasher Sequel

It’s a ridiculous movie. A poorly plotted rushed production that wastes the strong hook (if you’ll forgive the pun) of the original. And yet, if one sits back and lets the good times roll, I Still Know What You Did Last Summer has a lot to teach us about the right way to watch a stupid movie.

Advertisement

I Still Know is one of the best films to teach us this lesson thanks to its position in history. Despite not having a whiff of humor, it came out smack dab in the middle of the meta-slasher boom, where a killer couldn’t just go around carving up co-eds without a couple of winks to the camera. 1996’s Scream helped teach slasher fans how to be a savvy audience, giving viewers the exact tools they used to rip this shockingly straight-faced film to shreds.

Its reputation never recovered. And I’m not saying it should have. But what I am saying is that audiences can’t help but bring their biases into films. It’s only natural. There is no such thing as an objective experience of a work of art. Art wouldn’t be fun at all if there were. 

To that end, with a shift of expectations, I Still Know What You Did Last Summer can be utterly transformed. Mostly. It won’t suddenly become All About My Mother or anything. What I’m talking about is more like the difference between “Luke Skywalker was misused in The Last Jedi” and “It’s actually very fun that he drank colorful milk out of a space cow just to scare Daisy Ridley away.”

Stupid is As Stupid Does

The argument that “that movie was so stupid and thus you shouldn’t watch it” unravels when we ask one simple question: Would I Still Know What You Did Last Summer be better if it wasn’t stupid?

It was a 1998 slasher movie with a surprisingly low body count, an even lower gore quotient, and a co-lead (returning cast member Freddie Prinze Jr.) who barely interacts with the actual plot. What would it be about if the killer didn’t hack a karaoke machine to blare “I STILL KNOW” at Julie while she’s singing “I Will Survive?” Let’s be honest. It would have replaced all the scenes of rampant silliness with an even larger number of anodyne sequences where pretty people wander down dark hallways while the wind gently whooshes in the background.

Advertisement

The film may be making stupid choices, but at least it still makes choices. Sure, this resulted in far too much spice being tossed into the mix. It happens! But it’s better than having no flavor at all. If you’re the type to be first in line for a slasher sequel, you’re probably also the type to rewatch horror franchises over and over, so you know that encountering flavor is never a given. Just look at this film’s sequel, 2006’s I’ll Always Know What You Did Last Summer. A bowl of alphabet soup that spells out that title would offer more substance to the viewer than actually sitting down and watching the movie.

Stupidity as a Feature, Not a Flaw

If one approaches the film with the idea that stupidity is a feature, not a bug, it entirely reshapes the experience. I Still Know isn’t just a movie that makes stupid choices. It’s a movie that makes stupid choices with gusto, committing itself body and soul to every last second of its stupidity under the misguided but earnest assumption that it’s keeping you on the edge of your seat.  

That kind of zest still won’t float everyone’s boat, and that’s fine. But to err is human and to forgive, divine. I Still Know What You Did Last Summer offers us a chance to be divine and to have a blast while doing it. You just have to take the lesson it teaches to heart and approach it with the same commitment to its own unique energy that it brings to the table.

Brennan Klein is a millennial who knows way more about 80's slasher movies than he has any right to. He's a former host of the  Attack of the Queerwolf podcast and a current senior movie/TV news writer at Screen Rant. You can also find his full-length movie reviews on Alternate Ending and his personal blog Popcorn Culture. Follow him on Twitter or Letterboxd, if you feel like it.

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Editorials

The 10 Most Satisfying Deaths in Horror Movies

Published

on

Horror Press’ exploration of catharsis this month lends itself naturally to the topic of satisfying horror movie deaths. While murdering people who vex you in real life is rightly frowned upon, horror allows us to explore our darker sides. Fiction gives us the catharsis and relief to allow us to survive that ineradicable pox that is other people. To that end, here are the 10 most satisfying deaths in horror movies.

PS: It goes without saying that this article contains a few SPOILERS.

The 10 Most Satisfying Deaths in Horror Movies

#10 Franklin, The Texas Chain Saw Massacre

I ranked this death from the original Texas Chain Saw Massacre lowest for two reasons. First, I think Franklin’s whole vibe is a perfect fit for the unnerving, overwhelming atmosphere of Tobe Hooper’s masterpiece. Second, I think it’s important for representation that onscreen characters from marginalized groups be allowed to have flaws. That said, Franklin Hardesty is one of the most goddamn annoying characters in the history of cinema. Endless shrieking and raspberry-blowing will do that for ya. His death via chainsaw comes as a profound relief. His sister Sally spends the next 40 minutes or so screaming nonstop, and that’s considerably more peaceful.

#9 Lori, Happy Death Day

This is less about the character herself and more about Tree’s journey. After watching her time-loop for so long, being thwarted at every turn, Lori’s poison cupcake is a real gut-punch. Tree’s vengeance allows her to break out of the time loop once and for all (until the sequel). It also allows us to rejoice in the fact that her work to improve herself hasn’t been for naught.

#8 Billy, Scream (1996)

There are a hell of a lot of satisfying kills perpetrated upon Ghostfaces in the Scream franchise. However, the original still takes the cake. Sidney Prescott curtly refuses to allow a killer to plug a sequel at the end of her survival story. Instead, she plugs him in the head, saying, “Not in my movie.” It’s not just a great ending to a horror movie. It’s a big middle finger to sleazy teenage boyfriends the world over.

Advertisement

#7 Crispian, You’re Next

Ooh, when Erin finds out that this rotten man has knowingly brought her along to a home invasion… His attempt to charm (and bribe) her might have won over a weaker person. But in addition to putting her in danger, he has willingly had his family slaughtered for money. Erin won’t stand for that, and her takedown of yet another Toxic Horror Boyfriend is cause for celebration.

#6 Charles, Friday the 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan

Charles McCulloch might be one of the nastiest characters in film history. While school administrators are hardly any student’s best friend, his cold cruelty is downright abnormal. How he manages to be simultaneously overbearing and wicked to his niece, Rennie, I’ll never know. But thankfully, Jason Voorhees drowns him in a vat of toxic waste, removing the need to solve that mystery. Not all heroes wear capes. Sometimes they wear hockey masks.

#5 Tyler, The Menu

Up next on the tasting tray of cinema’s worst boyfriends, we have Tyler. He’s not technically Margot’s boyfriend, because she’s an escort he invited to a fancy dinner. But he should still land in the hall of fame. That’s because he brought her despite knowing ahead of time that nobody was meant to leave the restaurant alive. Thankfully, he gets one of the best Bad Boyfriend deaths of them all. He dies at his own hands. By hanging. After being thoroughly humiliated with proof that all the mansplaining in the world can’t make someone a good chef. Delectable.

#4 The Baby, Immaculate

You may remember this kill from my Top 10 Child Deaths article. The ending of Immaculate is (there’s no other word for it) immaculate. Shortly after Sister Cecilia learns that she has been unwillingly impregnated with the son of Christ, she gives birth. Instead of letting the church manipulate her further after violating her body, she smashes that godforsaken thing with a rock. In the process, she sheds years of ingrained doctrine and sets herself free once and for all. This is the ending that Antichrist movies have historically been too cowardly to give us. The fact that this character is a potential messiah makes it that much more cathartic.

#3 Carter, The Final Destination

I mean, come on. This guy is literally credited as “Racist” at the end of the movie. Pretty much every Final Destination movie has an asshole character who you crave to see die. But this epithet-spewing, cross-burning bigot is by far the worst of the bunch.

Advertisement

#2 Dean, Get Out

Racism comes in many forms, as Jordan Peele’s Get Out highlights. The Armitage family’s microaggressions quickly become macroaggressions, more than justifying Chris’ revenge slayings. While this whole portion of the movie is immensely satisfying, Dean’s death might just be the most cathartic. This is because he is killed via the antlers of a stuffed deer head. Chris uses the family’s penchant for laying claim to their prey’s bodies against them with this perfectly violent metaphor.

#1 Adrian, The Invisible Man (2020)

Here we have the final boss of Toxic Horror Boyfriends. This man is so heinously abusive that he fakes his own death in order to torment his ex even more. Cee using his own invisibility suit against him to stage his death by suicide is perfectly fitting revenge.

Continue Reading

Editorials

‘Ready or Not’ and the Cathartic Cigarette of a Relatable Final Girl

Published

on

I was late to the Radio Silence party. However, I do not let that stop me from being one of the loudest people at the function now. I randomly decided to see Ready or Not in theaters one afternoon in 2019 and walked out a better person for it. The movie introduced me to the work of a team that would become some of my favorite current filmmakers. It also confirmed that getting married is the worst thing one can do. That felt very validating as someone who doesn’t buy into the needing to be married to be complete narrative.

Ready or Not is about a fucked up family with a fucked up tradition. The unassuming Grace (Samara Weaving) thinks her new in-laws are a bit weird. However, she’s blinded by love on her wedding day. She would never suspect that her groom, Alex (Mark O’Brien), would lead her into a deadly wedding night. So, she heads downstairs to play a game with the family, not knowing that they will be hunting her this evening. This is one of the many ways I am different from Grace. I watch enough of the news to know the husband should be the prime suspect, and I have been around long enough to know men are the worst. I also have a commitment phobia, so the idea of walking down the aisle gives me anxiety. 

Grace Under Fire

Ready or Not is a horror comedy set on a wealthy family’s estate that got overshadowed by Knives Out. I have gone on record multiple times saying it’s the better movie. Sadly, because it has fewer actors who are household names, people are not ready to have that conversation. However, I’m taking up space this month to talk about catharsis, so let me get back on track. One of the many ways this movie is better than the latter is because of that sweet catharsis awaiting us at the end.

This movie puts Grace through it and then some. Weaving easily makes her one of the easiest final girls to root for over a decade too. From finding out the man she loves has betrayed her, to having to fight off the in-laws trying to kill her, as she is suddenly forced to fight to survive her wedding night. No one can say that Grace doesn’t earn that cigarette at the end of the film. As she sits on the stairs covered in the blood of what was supposed to be her new family, she is a relatable icon. As the unseen cop asks what happened to her, she simply says,In-laws.It’s a quick laugh before the credits roll, andLove Me Tenderby Stereo Jane makes us dance and giggle in our seats. 

Ready or Not Proves That Maybe She’s Better Off Alone

It is also a moment in which Grace is one of many women who survives marriage. She comes out of the other side beaten but not broken. Grace finally put herself, and her needs first, and can breathe again in a way she hasn’t since saying I do. She fought kids, her parents-in-law, and even her husband to escape with her life. She refused to be a victim, and with that cigarette, she is finally free and safe. Grace is back to being single, and that’s clearly for the best.

Advertisement

This Guy Busick and R. Christopher Murphy script is funny on the surface, even before you start digging into the subtext. The fact that Ready or Not is a movie where the happy ending is a woman being left alone is not wasted on me, though. While Grace thought being married would make her happy, she now has physical and emotional wounds to remind her that it’s okay to be alone. 

One of the things I love about this current era of Radio Silence films is that the women in these projects are not the perfect victims. Whether it’s Ready or Not, Abigail, or Scream (2022), or Scream VI, the girls are fighting. They want to live, they are smart and resourceful, and they know that no one is coming to help them. That’s why I get excited whenever I see Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett’s names appear next to a Guy Busick co-written script. Those three have cracked the code to give us women protagonists that are badasses, and often more dangerous than their would-be killers when push comes to shove. 

Ready or Not Proves That Commitment is Scarier Than Death

So, watching Grace run around this creepy family’s estate in her wedding dress is a vision. It’s also very much the opposite of what we expect when we see a bride. Wedding days are supposed to be champagne, friends, family, and trying to buy into the societal notion that being married is what we’re supposed to aspire to as AFABs. They start programming us pretty early that we have to learn to cook to feed future husbands and children.

The traditions of being given away by our fathers, and taking our husbands’ last name, are outdated patriarchal nonsense. Let’s not even get started on how some guys still ask for a woman’s father’s permission to propose. These practices tell us that we are not real people so much as pawns men pass off to each other. These are things that cause me to hyperventilate a little when people try to talk to me about settling down.

Marriage Ain’t For Everybody

I have a lot of beef with marriage propaganda. That’s why Ready or Not speaks to me on a bunch of levels that I find surprising and fresh. Most movies would have forced Grace and Alex to make up at the end to continue selling the idea that heterosexual romance is always the answer. Even in horror, the concept that “love will save the day” is shoved at us (glares at The Conjuring Universe). So, it’s cool to see a movie that understands women can be enough on their own. We don’t need a man to complete us, and most of the time, men do lead to more problems. While I am no longer a part-time smoker, I find myself inhaling and exhaling as Grace takes that puff at the end of the film. As a woman who loves being alone, it’s awesome to be seen this way. 

Advertisement

Ready or Note cigarette

The Cigarette of Singledom

We don’t need movies to validate our life choices. However, it’s nice to be acknowledged every so often. If for no other reason than to break up the routine. I’m so tired of seeing movies that feel like a guy and a girl making it work, no matter the odds, is admirable. Sometimes people are better when they separate, and sometimes divorce saves lives. So, I salute Grace and her cathartic cigarette at the end of her bloody ordeal.

I cannot wait to see what single shenanigans she gets into in Ready or Not 2: Here I Come. I personally hope she inherited that money from the dead in-laws who tried her. She deserves to live her best single girl life on a beach somewhere. Grace’s marriage was a short one, but she learned a lot. She survived it, came out the other side stronger, richer, and knowing that marriage isn’t for everybody.

Continue Reading

Horror Press Mailing List

Fangoria
Advertisement
Advertisement