TV
Lewks and Spooks: Horror’s Greatest Runways

One of the things I love most about horror is the degree to which it can realize its visual splendor. A horror film’s artistic expression lives and dies at the hands of its creative heads, and the only limit in bringing its surreal, otherworldly hellscapes and threatening villains to life lies with the budget and the MPAA. Our fear wouldn’t be as visceral without the talents of special effects artists, production designers, and the costume department. If your eyes don’t believe what they’re seeing is real, if even for a moment, how else would they pop out of their sockets?
In the same way, the queer community – an unyielding well of creativity and self-expression – wouldn’t be the same without its roots in the arts. That well is often tapped through fashion and the outward appearance we present to the world. Miuccia Prada once said, “Fashion is instant language,” which couldn’t be more correct in filmmaking. Upon meeting a new character, their wardrobe instantly tells us a lot about them, which is vital within a 90-minute runtime. On the flip side, it’s always scarier when everyday people are getting got. While many iconic villains lean heavily into slimy or sexy aesthetics, the main cast of your typical horror movie isn’t getting gutted in haute couture.
There are exceptions to this rule, wherein your faves are setting trends as they run for their lives, and, of course, said villains are regularly serving us grisly glamour as they slice and dice. So in honor of Pride month, the queer community and the fashion industry that is so heavily intertwined with identity and expression, let us strut down some of horror’s most infamous runways. Screw NYC and Milan; we’re heading into the shadows to explore the inner minds of serial killers and the depths of outer space for this fashion freakshow.
“In order to be irreplaceable, one must always be different.” – Coco Chanel
The Cell (2000)
Visionary director Tarsem Singh and his frequent collaborator, the late Oscar-winning costume designer Eiko Ishioka, materialize a nightmarish fantasy realm in this gory psychological thriller. Following a classicly early-aughts plot, cutting-edge technology enables social worker Catherine Deane (Jennifer Lopez) to enter the disturbingly picturesque mind of a serial killer to decode where his latest victim is being held – all while draped in gorgeous Gaultier-inspired designs. Themes of subservience, domination, and religious motifs are seen in the costuming and set design as Catherine loses herself in the killer’s demented world. Singh’s penchant for chains, endlessly flowing drapery, and a signature pop of red are scattered throughout. It’s a shame Rihanna’s single “S&M” came eleven years too late for some music video cross-promotion.
Hellraiser (1987 & 2022)
Delving deeper into the BDSM designer vault, Clive Barker’s novella adaptation includes many exciting chains and whips. Future Oscar-winning costume designer Joanna Johnston brought his twisted tale of the eternally tortured Cenobites to life – the story of each extra-dimensional demon’s kink being expressly told through their individual lewks. The 2022 reboot traded in PVC leather for pure fleshy goodness, desecrating Hell’s catwalk by splaying skin and muscle over their bodies like a nefarious Project Runway challenge. The phrase, “What’s your pleasure?” has never produced such a meaty response.
Saw (2004)
The beartrap headdress that started it all. Cary Elwes sawing off his own foot usually comes to mind when people think of James Wan’s breakout film, but the tetanus-encrusted deathtrap covering Shawnee Smith’s head is what first shocks us in the torture porn hit. Her downtrodden, heroin-chic character Amanda, eyes wide and dripping in mascara, shockingly manages to escape the contraption wired around her jaw and goes on to play a pivotal role throughout the franchise.
The Return of the Living Dead (1985)
Everybody loves Trash! This comedic punk rock middle finger to the über serious Night of the Living Dead is all fun and games, even after everyone starts getting their brains gnawed on. Starting off as a self-referential spinoff, no character embodies the film’s anarchic vibes more than Trash, played by genre actress Linnea Quigley, who sports a fire-engine red pompadour with a Bowie-via-the-local-mall outfit. Perhaps in a knowing wink to the sexed-up characters Quigley was famous for, Trash just wants to be ripped apart by a group of men. And reader, she certainly gets her wish.
“I’ll stop wearing black when they make a darker color.” – Wednesday Addams
The Craft (1996)
Witchy Los Angeles goths just hit different. The classic horror mashup of Heathers and Clueless is prime 90s teen fashion perfection, and our favorite coven’s style will leave you entranced. Costuming is key in creating a distinct before and after, and the film does an excellent job of evolving the girls’ wardrobe and attitudes once they harness their underworldly powers. The underdog hath left the bog when fan-favorite Nancy (Fairuza Balk) leads the pack in her mod leather witchy eleganza.
Scream’s Sweaters (1996)
Gale Weathers generally takes center stage when fashions of the Scream franchise are discussed, but in the original, it’s the sweaters that ground its characters and create relatability. Drew Barrymore, her wig, and that infamous beige sweater; Tatum’s lime green turtleneck that almost shows some skin; Stu and his chunky blood-soaked knit. When worn by iconic characters in a legendary movie, even the most casual outfits can stand the test of time. A special shoutout goes to Scream VI’s pumpkin lewk worn by newbie Anika – the ONLY time a bucket hat has worked.
Jennifer Tilly as Tiffany Valentine (1998 – present)
The Chucky franchise’s second, more photogenic face is fashion icon Jennifer Tilly/Tiffany Valentine. Tilly and her murderous doll counterpart are quite literally one and the same at this point, and it’s been a delight to watch as her gothic trailer park pinup aesthetic has evolved into a more refined lewk emblematic of Tilly’s real-life persona. It’s all 1950s diamonds and Dior by the time we see her in the later films and TV series, and her costuming is once again a testament to the way fashion weaves a transformative tale. In fact, given her glamorous 25+ year influence on the genre, it should come as no surprise to learn that she’s co-chair of the Golden Breastplate Award committee.
Bride of Frankenstein (1935)
Lighting strikes twice when it comes to Mary Shelley’s monstrous works of fiction, and the OG deadly bride on this list had audiences clutching their pearls during James Whale’s game-changing sequel. Despite not rising up until the film’s final moments, Elsa Lanchester cemented herself in horror history as the Monster’s unwilling beau. A vision in white, her floor-length gown and matching hair coils represent the birth of new life in the face of miscalculated evil, and the breakout sequel began a monstrous trend of its own at Universal.
Ready or Not (2019)
Samara Weaving delivers an appropriately modern take on the bride-in-crisis archetype by taking matters into her own hands and sticking it to her cultist in-laws like so many wish they could. Borrowing heavily from fan-favorite You’re Next, Weaving is put through the bloody ringer on her wedding day, and her lacey bodice becomes collateral damage. Burnt, bloodied, and tattered, it all builds to one hell of a final shot that perfectly encapsulates what a singular (and newly single) badass she’s become.
“You can have anything you want in life if you dress for it.” -Edith Head
The Love Witch (2016)
Auteur Anna Biller does it all in her charming feminist tribute to 1960s cinema. In total control over her film’s artistic vision, Biller examines female sexuality and the fear its power has over men through an unapologetically feminine lens of beauty and design. Inspired by retired fashion label Gunne Sax, which specialized in blending the empire waists of Renaissance culture with 19th-century Victorian patterns, she hand-crafted many of its costumes. As a result, it’s a joy to watch the hopelessly romantic witch Elaine look for love in all the wrong ways, whether she’s wearing a go-go dress, a baby pink sun hat, or one of Countess Luann de Lesseps’ statement necklaces.
Last Night in Soho (2021)
Another deep dive into far-out 1960s fashion, Edgar Wright’s impeccably stylish murder mystery transcends time and space. Its leads Sandy (Anya Taylor Joy) and Eloise (Thomasin McKenzie) couldn’t be more different, and that dichotomy is explicitly seen through their clothing. Yet, as visions of Sandy in all her Brigitte Bardot and Twiggy glory continue to act as a muse for Eloise’s blooming talent as a designer, we learn the grass is not always greener. Beauty can be empowering, but it can also be one’s downfall.
In Fabric (2019)
Peter Strickland’s bizarre film about an insidious red dress that ultimately destroys whoever wears it is an underrated gem. Blending comedy with surreal and witchy horror, it examines our relationship with clothing and the people who sell it to us. The natural flow of the wrap dress, a signature creation of Diane von Furstenberg, allows this killer garment to ambush people of all shapes and sizes. Bonus points for the Suspiria-like coven of department store clerks, who add an extra dose of WTF.
Blood and Black Lace (1965)
Mario Bava’s early-giallo classic, in which a killer murders a gaggle of models one by one, was critically panned during its release. However, it has since become a favorite of many famous filmmakers, and with a luxurious title like that, who can blame them? The killer’s face is obscured by a stocking (fun fact: Atonement used a Chanel stocking over the camera lens to give the film a dreamier look), as he slays our Italian bombshells in a way that intersects violence with fashion in previously unseen ways. It may favor style over substance, but its tableau is bloody stunning.
The Neon Demon (2016)
Perhaps the most quintessentially in-vogue film on this list, Nicholas Winding Refn’s slow burn about Jesse (Elle Fanning), a naive model new to Los Angeles, is like watching fashion week on acid. Designers like Armani, Giles, and Saint Laurent supplied pieces for the production, and their dangerous beauty is necessary to bring this “adult fairy tale” to life. We can examine what it means to be beautiful and the succubus-like nature of narcissism and jealousy while the camera carefully frames the scene like a glitzy, new-age baroque painting. And if its lethargic pace makes you feel antsy, a wild final act will make it all worth the wait.
The Hunger (1983)
Costume designer Milena Canonero, who is responsible for the wardrobe iconography in many of Wes Anderson’s films, showcases the elitism of well-to-do vampires Miriam and John Blaylock (Catherine Deneuve and David Bowie) in Tony Scott’s debut film. This overtly erotic thriller proves nothing is off limits for the upper echelon, and outfits that mix classic Saint Laurent and Hollywood glam with broad 1980s shoulder pads and a touch of Egyptian flair make it all the more unattainable. The film was so polarizing that it inspired Ryan Murphy’s equally polarizing American Horror Story: Hotel, which gave us Gaga and gore — thank you, Tony.
Queen of the Damned (2002)
A sequel to Anne Rice’s Interview with the Vampire, this film left critics and audiences wanting more. Still, it gave us the late, great singer Aaliyah’s outstanding performance as the vampire Queen Akasha in her final acting role. She contorts her body like a snake draped in an Egyptian-inspired headpiece and chest of jewels, and the performance certainly made its mark on pop culture. Her co-star, the often shirtless Stuart Townsend as the vampire Lestat, made audiences equally salivate in his Alexander McQueen-inspired low-rise leather pants. Have mercy!
Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1992)
It wouldn’t be a list on fashion in horror if I mentioned Francis Ford Coppola’s vampire epic, which won Eiko Ishioka an Oscar for her work in costume design. Coppola is quoted as saying he considered the actors the “jewels” of the film, so he wanted the wardrobe to represent his gems accordingly. Ishioka’s designs are defiant and otherworldly, depicting the changes Dracula and the women in his life undergo during its dark odyssey. Two standouts include Dracula’s red armor, which resembles living muscle tissue, and the wedding dress of his short-lived bride Lucy, a miraculous confection of white lace that looks like Vera Wang and Rodarte had a field day creating a wild collaboration in the 19th century.
Death Becomes Her (1992)
Meryl Streep and Goldie Hawn are silver screen legends, but personally, the true fashion-forward standout of this dark comedy is the ageless Isabella Rosellini as Lisle Von Rhuman. Her mysterious character bestows the gift of immortality upon the iconic duo and does it all while looking like ancient royalty. Her slicked-back bob and bejeweled breastplate are regal AF, and you would not want to cross her while she’s donning her oversized quilted shawl collar shaman lewk. If the film is about aging women taking back their power, Rosellini proves she’s the HBIC.
“What ‘normal’ people would perceive as ugly, I can usually see something of beauty in it.” – Alexander McQueen
The Lure (2015)
Polish director Agnieszka Smoczynska serves up a European glam rock mermaid musical like no other – really, there’s nothing else like it in existence. A murderous take on The Little Mermaid, the film follows mer-sisters Silver (Marta Mazurek) and Golden (Michalina Olszańska) as they perform their titular show at a nightclub and navigate life and love on land. It is flamboyant excess, and it is easy to be lured in by the extravagant musical numbers and grotesque special effects.
Under the Skin (2014)
An atypical film for both this list and in general, Jonathan Glazer’s dreary tale follows an alien being that looks like Scarlett Johansson as it makes a journey of self-discovery in a Scottish seaside town. Very slice-of-life, it often uses non-actors and is entirely unassuming aside from Johansson’s famous face and the visually abstract scenes of human harvesting dispersed throughout. However, in the film’s final moments, we bare witness to the alien’s true form – a shimmery matte black humanoid with no distinct features. The sorrowful longing bubbling underneath the surface finally boils over, and themes of beauty and how our grasp on it drives our assimilation into society become clear.
Silent Hill (2006)
If you’re a fan of video games, you almost certainly know about Pyramid Head. As the judge, jury, and executioner of the foggy demonic town of Silent Hill, PH exemplifies androgynous couture. A metallic pyramid helm sits atop a chiseled torso that melts into a floor-length skirt stitched together of flesh. Don’t fuck with Pyramid Head.
Pink Flamingoes (1972)
Drag performer Divine made his mark on culture in John Waters’ divisive outsider comedy, where his character Babs worked to maintain her self-proclaimed title as “the filthiest person alive.” Holding a handgun cocked and ready to fire in a blood-red mermaid dress, Divine clawed his way into the minds of anyone who came across the film or its iconic poster. Fashion influences public perception, and this divine fit filled our minds with a morbid curiosity about the drag legend.
“I wanna dress you up in silk taffeta.” – Lady Gaga
Doctor Sleep (2019)
Rebecca Ferguson gives a haunting performance as the psychic vampire villainess, Rose the Hat, in the sequel to Stephen King’s The Shining. Her charisma and beauty seem effortless, exuding quiet confidence in pseudo-bohemian lewks with a single braid she wears much better than your average Jedi. Rose the Hat also kidnaps and murders children for their life essence to retain her youthful glow, so there’s that.
Crimson Peak (2015)
“Gowns. Gorgeous gothic gowns.” That should be the only thing you’re muttering to yourself throughout Guillermo del Toro’s Victorian love story. Costume designer Kate Hawley draws a line in the sand between good vs. evil and employs a particular light and dark aesthetic for the film’s leads. Mia Wasikowska, as Edith, wanders through her haunted new home adorned with puffy sleeves resembling a butterfly or moth, and Jessica Chastain slinks about the shadows in corsets and tightly fitted dresses, snatched for the gods and ready to pounce.
The Skin I Live In (2011)
Pedro Almodóvar’s unconventional and eccentric story about a surgeon (Antonio Banderas) who holds a woman (Elena Anaya) captive and grafts an unbreakable synthetic skin onto her body is magnificently minimalist in its fashion. The sterilized athleisure look the mysterious woman wears is very vapid “LA intellectual,” and the subdued nature of the costuming only adds to the film’s list of questions.
Trick ‘r Treat (2007)
You didn’t think I’d leave out Sam, the Pumpkin Prince of All Hallow’s Eve, did you? Sam is everything – his name is a shortened form of the Gaelic festival marking Halloween itself, he wears a cute-as-heck pumpkin lewk, and he brandishes a razor-sharp lollipop as a murder weapon for all those who don’t maintain tradition. Every time he dispatches another victim, you can’t help but giggle and scream, “Slay!”
Beetlejuice (1988)
Tim Burton’s supernatural goth classic will soon have a sequel after over 30 years, but its avant-garde fashion has always remained fresh in our brains. From Lydia Deetz (Winona Ryder) and her strange and unusual red wedding dress to her mother, Delia (Catherine O’Hara), who makes outrageous style choices work to her advantage, every frame is dripping in Hot Topic meets Betsey Johnson decadence. A particularly inspired look comes when Delia wears what looks like a black nitrile glove on her head as a fastener. Mother snapped with that one.
Jason X (2001)
The final film on our list levitates us beyond Earth’s atmosphere into the dark recesses of space and, somehow, right back into the clutches of Jason Vorhees. As previously mentioned, slasher fashion tends to lean basic as hell, but apparently, someone resurrected an early 2000s lookbook in 2455, and it works! Most agree that style at the turn of the millennium was tacky and tryhard futurism, but when you bring it into actual space, somehow it becomes campy couture. Halter tops, mesh, and subdued blues and silvers litter the screen, and sexed-up Power Rangers fighting mecha Jason in an airlock has never looked better.
“Whoever said that money can’t buy happiness simply didn’t know where to go shopping.” – Bo Derek
And there you have it! Horror’s greatest runways have been decided. The language of fashion and a film’s wardrobe speaks for itself – whether resonating with deeper themes, illustrating character arcs, or solely there make you jealous. The heroes and villains discussed here are unrivaled, but no one’s stopping you from using them to inspire your self-expression through patterns and fabric. And as always, if you have any questions or complaints, take them up with the Miranda Priestly of Horror Press
TV
Interview with the Vampire: Queer Love & Vampires on TV

An age-old question has always been, “If you could live forever, would you?” As a queer person of color, I have always found the concept of immortality fascinating. Would being immortal improve things, or would my life remain unchanged? Would I lose my humanity as centuries pass? Having been a devoted reader of Anne Rice for many years, I became convinced that the only way to achieve immortality and find answers to my questions was to become a vampire. Imagine watching this version of Interview with the Vampire as a TV show for the first time. Like a human about to become food for the damned, I was enamored.
The series’ setup was masterfully done. Daniel Molloy, a gay man and reporter, is in the home of Louis de Pointe du Lac, a vampire. Louis introduces Daniel to his assistant, Rashid, who we later discover is the vampire Armand and Louis’ new lover. The inclusion of several queer main characters in this show was a refreshing change.
Daniel is the conductor, guiding the narrative with probing questions in every episode. The story unfolds in modern times and throughout the past, as Louis revisits his memories when Daniel seeks answers. Most questions focus on Louis’ maker and first male lover, the former human French aristocrat-turned-vampire Lestat de Lioncourt. The transitions connecting the story between periods flow seamlessly, like blood flowing through the veins to the heart and brain. See? This series had such a profound impact on me that it inspired me to become a poet.
Interview with the Vampire: A Queer Interracial Love Story
If you read the Anne Rice books, you know how Lestat fell in love with Louis and transformed him into his immortal partner. In subtext, anyway. The show not only embraced the idea that these two characters were a couple but also explored all aspects of their relationship: the good, the bad, the human soul, and the vampire spirit. Oh, and Louis is a Black man in the TV adaptation, making them a queer interracial couple. How’s that for a bit of razzle-dazzle?
“You could be a lot of things in New Orleans, but an openly gay Negro man was not one of them.” Louis’s words imprinted on me. He was hurting from internal struggle during his early days as a fledgling. Accepting yourself as queer when you have been living life as a straight person must have been jarring, especially at that time. Lestat knew what it was like coming to terms with queerness and vampirehood. However, I am not entirely convinced he understood intersectionality, or maybe he didn’t care.
Louis soon lost his family after he was turned. They realized he was different and even implied that he had consorted with the devil. His family also expressed concerns about his relationship with Lestat, particularly his deeply religious brother, Paul. For those who come from a POC ethnic background, being queer can be a death sentence. Some communities would rather accept you as a bloodsucking demon than as a person living outside a heteronormative lifestyle. In this case, however, Louis’s family didn’t accept him either way. Talk about a stake to the heart.
Navigating Queerness and Race in 1910s New Orleans
The show effectively balances fantasy and reality, allowing viewers almost to blur the lines between the two. It’s important to remember that during the 1910s, there was a significant rise in racial tension. Louis, a brothel owner catering to white customers and possessing more wealth than the average enslaved person, still faced opposition. White businessmen conspired against him to ensure his business would fail, as they aimed to shut it down. Louis found the man behind the plan. He openly expressed his disdain for Louis, revealing that he found him repugnant because of his race and sexual orientation.
Louis was justified in killing him. IDC.
I encountered a situation I never thought possible: even after gaining all the immortal gifts, you can still be vulnerable to human hatred. It shouldn’t have surprised me, as being queer gives you an automatic disadvantage in life. And being a person of color? Forget about it. No amount of vampiric blood or money would change your worth to those who deem you as lesser.
We observe how Louis’s immortality made him more at ease with his sexuality. It served as a gateway to experiences beyond human understanding. I am fond of metaphors, so I see becoming a vampire as a symbol of puberty and open-mindedness. Witnessing his struggle, I embraced this flawed character because he felt real. I also felt validation, as I am sure many others did. In the end, Louis was able to find his voice. That to which I say, “Yas, my undead queen!”
Queer Love Can Be Toxic Too
Unfortunately, as Daniel painfully noted during his interview with Louis, Lestat wasn’t the supportive partner he could have been. Instead of genuine guidance, Louis was met with misdirected anger. There was certainly love between them, but it was overshadowed.
Lestat’s love was as passionate as his wrath. He had little patience for Louis’ reluctance to accept all facets of being a vampire. While he enjoyed drinking from humans, Louis would feed from rats. This would cause intense fights between them. Lestat was disgusted by Louis’ shame and guilt regarding his desire for human blood.
While Louis was indeed a victim to some extent in his abusive relationship with Lestat, the show effectively portrayed the complexities, both positive and negative, of their dynamic. This is a reminder that both heterosexual and non-heterosexual relationships can have many similarities.
Claudia’s Tragic Tale: The Cost of Toxic Parenting
I’m not here to romanticize Louis’ toxic traits and embellish his victimhood. Let’s be real: Louis pressured Lestat to create Claudia, an eternal child who later resents her neglectful fathers for bringing her into existence. This complicates matters, and Louis dared to act like he didn’t want a daughter, which is absurd. I am not suggesting that Louis being dropped from the sky during a domestic fight was justified, nor that Louis and Claudia plotting to murder Lestat with poisoned blood was the best solution to their problems. I’m saying that these two immortal drama queens needed therapy as they destroyed everything around them.
A Scorpio and Libra dating is diabolical work.
The real victim here was Claudia. Trapped in a child’s body, never knowing what becoming an adult truly means. Her toxic and abusive parents were too busy caring about everything and everyone else but her. Relatable content. Might I add that having this character as a person of color was a beautiful touch? Interview with the Vampire made a statement by featuring Black main characters. Come on, an immortal interracial couple with a Black vampire child—scandalous AF.
I could go on about Claudia, but I’m sorry, girl. I have to keep talking about your dramatic dads. As you once said, “Picked another one over me!”
The Impact of Racism and Homophobia on Immortal Lives
Each episode left me feeling conflicted about what to be angry about. Should I be upset with Lestat’s cruelty, Louis’ eagerness to please, Daniel’s probing questions that force accountability, or Armand’s manipulative behavior to keep Louis around and ensure he resents Lestat? Or perhaps I should focus on the racist and homophobic characters who complicate this dysfunctional vampire family’s existence? Probably all of the above. Seeing the metaphorical sun draw near while vampires toy with its flames served as a reminder that these powerful night creatures still possessed human flaws. That’s the point, isn’t it?
I would be flattered if a vampire saw me, fell in love, and decided to make me their forever partner. However, I would not have enjoyed being isolated from my family and forced to rush transition from human to bloodsucker. All the while, I would be gaslighted and abused, which in turn would make me a toxic partner as well.
As their story unfolds, so does the drama. The characters change, and these changes are sometimes for the worse. These dads and their dramatics led to Claudia’s fiery death. No, this isn’t a spoiler because this happened in the books, so don’t come at me. The potential to have had an enriching and fulfilling home figuratively and literally went up in flames. This scenario could have been about a heterosexual relationship, and the message would not have lost its value. Now that’s how you know the writing is genius.
Anne Rice is Queen
It’s mentioned earlier that Anne Rice was the queen of subtext, so the writers of this series ate in fleshing out the characters in the Vampire Chronicles Universe. This show provided us with everything we desired: romance, lust, passion, and deceit—the perfect recipe for a gay vampire novella. I know I didn’t highlight the positives of this vamp relationship, but that’s overdone in other gay and straight stories. I aimed to address the unpleasant and painful aspects, so you’re welcome.
While we wait for the new season to air in 2026, I recommend rewatching the episodes as a refresher. They’re streaming on both Amazon Video and AMC+. Or if you want something more intimate, walk around at night and hope for the undead to pay you mind and offer you everlasting life.
JK. Don’t do that. Please.
TV
Why Max’s ‘Velma’ Failed: A Lesson for Hollywood’s IP Revivals
Hollywood is an industry of extreme risk and reward. In a world where high cost, star-studded films often attracts distracted viewers, studios have relied on a tried-and-true method of mitigating risk: reviving existing IP from their back catalog. At the same time, modern audiences are smarter, more critical, and less willing to be handed reheated slop, as demonstrated by critical and audience backlash to the modern trend of rebooting existing animated franchises for live-action. To stand out in a crowded field where audience discussion goes beyond the confines of the work water cooler to the limitless chatrooms of the internet, a reboot needs a spin, an angle to set it apart from the rest.

Hollywood is an industry of extreme risk and reward. In a world where high cost, star-studded films often attracts distracted viewers, studios have relied on a tried-and-true method of mitigating risk: reviving existing IP from their back catalog. At the same time, modern audiences are smarter, more critical, and less willing to be handed reheated slop, as demonstrated by critical and audience backlash to the modern trend of rebooting existing animated franchises for live-action. To stand out in a crowded field where audience discussion goes beyond the confines of the work water cooler to the limitless chatrooms of the internet, a reboot needs a spin, an angle to set it apart from the rest. So what happened with HBO’s Velma?
Velma’s Bold Reimagination: A Scooby-Doo Without Scooby
When Warner Bros.’s adult animated show Velma was announced in 2021 with executive producer, screenwriter, and voice actress Mindy Kaling aboard to voice the titular character, fans of the Scooby-Doo franchise seemed somewhat excited, though hesitant about the premise of an adult-orientated Scooby Doo show. This speculation was only amplified as outcry emerged at reports of the show race-swapping existing members of the Mystery Incorporated gang in an attempt to approach the characters’ origins through new, more contemporary lenses. Further criticism was thrown at the show upon the reveal that the series’ mascot Scooby-Doo would not be featured, sending fans spiraling before the show even premiered. However, while Velma’s creative reimagination does at times cause confusion, it isn’t what ultimately causes the show to fail despite two seasons and a Halloween special.
Upon its 2023 premiere, Velma almost instantly gained fire from all corners of the internet, as out-of-context clips of the show filled the internet’s timelines. Fans immediately criticized the show’s new tone, which failed to modernize and age up the franchise’s humor by instead resorting to potty humor and jabbing at millennials and ‘wokeness’. For most viewers, the show didn’t resonate as anything more than an adult comedy with a Scooby-Doo paint job.
Fan Backlash: Race-Swapping and Tone Missteps in Velma
While the show attempts to engage with its own history, it fails the most in its conceit, reimagining Velma as less of a clever, critical investigator and more as a loud-mouthed troll who annoys her way through her mysteries while occasionally connecting two plus two. The show’s supporting cast is reimagined to some success, with Glenn Howerton portraying a spoiled, physically & emotionally stunted Fred, Constance Wu bringing an attitude and a criminal mischievousness to Daphne, and Sam Richardson trying his hardest to defy Shaggy’s stoner archetype. Though the voice cast succeeds at delivering the occasional joke or absurdism, the show’s tone is perhaps hampered by its ambition.
Velma aims not only to break new ground as an adult-orientated Scooby Doo adaptation, but also create new, modernized versions of the characters, incorporate high school hijinks, and establish a sense of risk and mystery that engages an older audience. Scooby Doo as a franchise has almost always been procedural, with your classic monster-of-the-week or man-in-a-monster-mask-of-the-week storyline. Most of the payoff from the original show and the more beloved movies is that each episode delivers on mysteries, monsters, and hilarious hijinks as the more competent members of Mystery Inc. fend off Shaggy and Scooby’s incompetency. Velma is the second attempt at a serialized Scooby Doo show after Scooby Doo! Mystery Incorporated, a show intended for older child audiences that continued to engage with the monster-of-the-week format while developing character relationships and a multi-season arc. However, Velma abandons the weekly mystery that was critical for Scooby Doo! Mystery Incorporated needs to have a foundation to hold onto as that series’ serial elements develop. At almost all opportunities, the show seems like it’s doing too much, juggling too many storylines, reimaginings, and trying its hardest to cram in parody and humor.
Where Velma Went Wrong: A Weak Mystery and Overloaded Plot
From the get go, Velma follows the origin of Velma’s mystery solving, detailing how Velma’s curiosity resulted in her mother mysteriously disappearing with few clues to aid in her rediscovery. Two years later, a traumatized Velma blames herself for her mother’s disappearance and swears not to solve mysteries again, even as the brains of popular local girls start disappearing, creating a rumor mill about a local serial killer. Most of the show’s issues come from the fact that the show fails to find interest in the group dynamics of Mystery Inc, instead stapling together loosely related plotlines for not one, but two seasons without officially assembling Mystery Inc. Even after critical and audience outcry at the show, the second season doubles down with a continuation of the storyline about Velma’s missing mother and how she’s tied to weird doings in the town. While the show tries to respond to some of its outcry by incorporating more existing Scooby Doo characters, it never quite figures out what it’s trying to do, once again resulting in a season that feels like a poorly rebranded adult comedy forced into a Scooby Doo mold.
While Velma’s lack of careful plotting and consideration of the show’s source material practically breaks it on a conceptual level, the show isn’t all misses. The voice cast manages to stand apart from long-standing predecessors, lending unique angles and opportunities to set this iteration of Mystery Inc. apart from past re-angles. The show’s humor, while a bit too reliant on the crudeness and depravity of early 2010s adult animation, occasionally hits a laugh by poking apart the show’s own absurdity. At its most meta, the show comes across as clever, tearing at the teens solving mysteries tropes the original set to establish, while struggling to lean into the elements that would appeal to long-term fans. The fact that Scrappy-Doo makes a major appearance before Scooby Doo and the show’s hesitancy to become what is so beloved of the franchise ultimately hits the brakes on being anything memorable before the show’s abrupt cancellation following its Halloween special.
What’s Next for Scooby-Doo: Netflix’s Live-Action Series
Despite Velma’s failings and fumblings, there remains some hope for the Scooby-Doo franchise despite Warner Bros. repeated insistence on canceling completed Scooby-Doo films intended for both direct-to-streaming and theatrical markets. As of April 2025, Netflix is moving ahead with an 8-episode live-action series that will serve as the first television live-action adaptation of the source material. Showrunners Josh Appelbaum and Scott Rosenberg will tackle the origin of Mystery Inc, which multiple Scooby-Doo adaptations have tackled in the past; however, details remain sparse on the project. The project seems to be produced with a production team with diverse backgrounds, with some members hailing from CW projects and other network programming while others have streaming experience.
As a lifelong Scooby-Doo fan, the most I can hope for this new adventure for the franchise is that it continues to rely on the DNA of the show that made it initially successful. From the original series to the many spinoffs and remakes it has produced, the show has always been about solving mysteries, the hijinks needed to solve them, and how what appears isn’t exactly what it actually is. The hope is that this new series won’t forget the mysteries, will commit fully to its new angle at the source material, and remember what is most beloved by Scooby-Doo fans is the characters & how they navigate hijinks. We don’t need a shot-for-shot live-action remake or a gritty rework to be happy, we just need those who are taking swings at the franchise to be passionate and genuine about using it as a foundation to expand upon, rather than create a totally new show with a Scooby-Doo makeup job.