Film Fests
[REVIEW] BHFF 2024: ‘Who’s Watching’ (I’m Watching! And I Will Watch Again!)
Who’s Watching follows Caleb (Zachary Ray Sherman), a weird, creepy, and downright off-putting, self-obsessed loner. Caleb finds himself creating a “documentary” at his uncle’s business. The “documentary” quickly reveals itself to be centered around his coworker Krista (Gracie Gillam), turning from oddly quirky to insidiously dangerous. The narration around Caleb’s film gets murky when one of his band’s friends, Tawnia (Olivia Luccardi), enters the picture. Who is filming who? And who, exactly, is watching?
It’s officially time to apologize for something heinous I said years ago. I’ve grown and learned from my mistakes. Out of all the film genres, horror has been known to fall into phases. Post 9/11, the horror genre saw an influx of angry slasher films, like The Hills Have Eyes, the Friday the 13th remake, and a rise in zombie films. The xenophobic fear felt by countries all around the world propelled these types of films into horror’s zeitgeist. Around the mid-aughts, the genre would make a hard transition into an overabundance of low-budget found footage films like Who’s Watching.
Who’s Watching Proves Found Footage Horror Isn’t Dying Anytime Soon
While there may or may not have been political or social reasons behind this shift, I thought it would just be a phase. It’s not. Many times, I’ve gone on record, saying found footage will hit a plateau and the subgenre will die out. But with films like The Outwaters, Malibu Horror Story, Horror in the High Desert, Strange Harvest: Occult Murder in the Inland Empire, The Ceremony is About To Begin, Frogman, and Hell House LLC Origins: The Charmichael Manor, it’s clear I was wrong. So what was it that finally flipped the switch in my head? What was the film that made me realize I couldn’t have been more wrong?
Who’s Watching follows Caleb (Zachary Ray Sherman), a weird, creepy, and downright off-putting, self-obsessed loner. Caleb finds himself creating a “documentary” at his uncle’s business. The “documentary” quickly reveals itself to be centered around his coworker Krista (Gracie Gillam), turning from oddly quirky to insidiously dangerous. The narration around Caleb’s film gets murky when one of his band’s friends, Tawnia (Olivia Luccardi), enters the picture. Who is filming who? And who, exactly, is watching?
Tim Kasher: Musician, Filmmaker, Triple Threat
Writer/director Tim Kasher is one hell of a filmmaker. I had no clue he was the composer of the brilliant film My Suicide (aka Archie’s Final Project) which stars Zachary Ray Sherman. When the film was introduced, I found out just how much people love Kasher. His band Cursive was mentioned, and the house went wild. Kasher is an astounding composer, musician, and filmmaker—a real triple threat. Who’s Watching is Kasher’s sophomore feature, and it’s a gorgeous blend of found footage and traditional filmmaking. It’s one of the few times a found footage film answers the question of how the film we’re watching was edited (with music, titles, etc.).
Mastering Found Footage Storytelling
When it comes to found footage/POV filmmaking, the lead characters, or at least those with most of the screen time, must succeed for the film to work. The most frustrating FF/POV films are those with constantly peaked audio and actors who think loud and annoying is an acting choice. Luckily for Kasher, he struck gold with his three leads.
Zachary Ray Sherman excels as a red-pilled 4Chan incel. Even though Sherman is handsome in the real world, his behind-the-dollar-store haircut and general unpleasantness craft the character of Caleb into a truly terrifying antagonist. What’s most disheartening about his performance is its raw authenticity. Even when his character acts in a way that seems over the top, it’s unfortunately not too far off from something you’d see in a YouTube true crime breakdown video. The character of Caleb was etched into my brain long after the credits rolled. It left me looking over my shoulder while waiting for the L train to arrive.
Gracie Gillam is just a pure joy to watch. From her start in 2011’s Fright Night, to a stint on Vampire Diaries, all the way through the highly underappreciated Z Nation, Gillam has made quite a name for herself in the horror scene. Who’s Watching is another stellar mark in her glowing oeuvre. She plays the damsel in distress incredibly well and absolutely makes the finale her bitch.
Olivia Luccardi is the epitome of the “good for her” trope. Like Gillam, Luccardi is no stranger to horror as she played Yara in It Follows (you know, the person with the clamshell eReader!). There’s a real slow burn for Tawnia, she’s naturally unassuming until you realize what’s actually going on. Let’s just say, there’s a twist in the film that had nearly the entire theater gasping.
Why Who’s Watching Stands Out
It’s clear that Kasher had a distinct vision with Who’s Watching, and that vision is horrific. During the Q&A after the film, Luccardi revealed that while they were told what to film, they were allowed to make the shooting scenes their own. And, to me, that’s what makes Who’s Watching such an impressive feature. Allowing your actors to exist within their characters and let them film what they think needs to be filmed, or what they think they would notice if they were in this predicament, which adds another level of credence to this film.
Found footage and POV films rarely have deep characters and character development. Who’s Watching is a film that knows what it is, what it needs to be, and what story is necessary to tell at certain points. From the deep character developments to the astounding visual choices, this film is one that you will not forget for a long time. I have no clue if Tim Kasher and Joel Potrykus know each other, but their styles are strikingly similar while still existing within their own unique and artistic worlds. If the two of them got together and made an anthology film, I think the world would implode.
You’ve never seen a found footage film like Who’s Watching. The only question you have to ask yourself as you leave the theater is, “How’d you like that fucking movie?”
Film Fests
Overlook Film Festival: ‘Exit 8’ Review
If you’re at the intersection of video games and horror, then you know not all video game film adaptations are created equally. For every Silent Hill (2006), Werewolves Within, or Detention (2019), there is a lot of heartbreak and titles we’re still trying to forget. Which is why, when Kotake Create’s beloved Exit 8 video game was tapped to become a film, we held our collective breath. How would this quick psychological nightmare transfer to a feature-length film? Would the filmmaker chosen understand the assignment? Luckily, the movie works overall, and horror and game nerds have another title in the win column.
In Case You Missed It
Exit 8 puts gamers into the shoes of an unseen protagonist who is stuck in a subway station. Players soon realize that this location is not what it seems. They are also tasked with spotting anomalies in hopes of making it to the eighth level and (hopefully) back to the real world. Some of the anomalies are subtle, some are anxiety-inducing, and some leave you wanting to scream WTF? However, the game is a pretty quick introduction to liminal spaces and self-gaslighting.
The film, written by Kentaro Hirase and Genki Kawamura, understands what made the game effective. They even keep and elevate some of the anomalies that were my personal favorites. The duo also builds three very distinct characters to keep us from sitting for 95 minutes of vibes.
Walking Man (Yamato Kochi) is not just the creepy guy making circles in this hallway with us in the film. He gets a full arc in his chapter that informs us he was a human who panicked and made the wrong choice. He is now doomed to spend eternity here as part of others’ nightmarish quests. While all of the performances are great, Kochi brings a humanity and sadness to the role that was unexpected. He finds ways of using his character’s repetitive nature as a way to add subtle layers. This makes the shift into his chapter feel more alive, frantic, and heartbreaking. We know this journey isn’t going to end well for him, but it’s hard not to fully invest and feel that heartbreak anyway.
It’s Not All Great at Exit 8
Exit 8 plays with us in the beginning before shifting from first-person perspective to reveal our protagonist will be Lost Man (Kazunari Ninomiya). He and his girlfriend are having a moment when he ends up in this subway station on a loop. Their phone conversation reveals she’s pregnant, so Lost Man is having a bad day before getting stuck in liminal limbo. This, on its own, is fine. However, after a lot of laps, he meets The Boy (Naru Asanuma) and discovers he is not an anomaly.
The Boy ties Lost Man and Walking Man’s stories together. He tries to assist both of them on their journeys while being too afraid to speak for most of his screentime. Again, all of the performances are great, but a kid killing it with a mostly silent role is highly impressive. His relationship with these two broken and frightened men is believable and palpable. He and Lost Man specifically bond and form a lovely duo that, unfortunately, underscores the pregnant girlfriend to lead to a very pro-life message.
Exit 8’s Politics Derail the Horror
Kawamura directed the hell out of Exit 8, and it’s a good time. However, it’s hard to wash away the very heavy swerve into pro-life territory in 2026. Especially as a person with ovaries who lives in a country that doesn’t want me to have autonomy. Horror is political, and this game has so many things that could have been expanded on. The insertion of an anti-choice layer into a film centered on three male characters (at three very different stages of life) is wild. I personally hated it because, aside from that, it does capture the vibes of the game. It feels like watching someone piss in the lemonade on a hot summer day.
Film Fests
The Crypt Keeper Takes Overlook Film Festival 2026
You would be hard-pressed to find a horror fan who doesn’t have fond memories of Tales From the Crypt. Some of you may be like me and watched episodes as a child while losing battles with insomnia. Others may have been lucky enough to get their hands on physical copies that allow constant rewatches. Quite a few people watched Tales from the Cryptkeeper and got a more age appropriate introduction. Whatever your journey, John Kassir’s Crypt Keeper is still crystal clear in your mind.
The people behind The Overlook Film Fest are very much aware of this. So, they asked Kassir to join the fest on day one to say hello to all the boils and ghouls. Kassir and the puppet that made him an icon were the main attractions of the Opening Night Second Line Parade presented by Shudder. Kassir met and posed with too many fans to count while effortlessly slipping into his Crypt Keeper voice and cackle. He seemed delighted to spark joy for so many horror fiends whose character he helped shape. Kassir, known for his sharp and quick humor, is also a surprisingly warm person. His energy is almost a cross between Robin Williams and Robert Englund. After a few seconds, you realize he’s one of us, weirdos (complementary) and is having just as much (if not more) fun as his legion of fans.
Kassir Didn’t Just Wake Up as the Crypt Keeper in One Day
After the parade, it was the after-party, or panel. Kassir sat down with Matt Donato (Daily Dead) and Perri Nemiroff (Collider) to discuss his career. Kassir was reminded that he was a theater kid and learned that he and Scott Bakula (Quantum Leap) came up together and are still friends. Kassie also shared that the two of them were approached for Full House. Bakula for the role that went to Bob Saget and Kassir for Dave Coulier’s. As a horror kid who grew up in the 90s, I would’ve lived my best life with Kassir in the basement of the Tanner House.
Kassir told the crowd about how he was encouraged to do Star Search even though he didn’t think it was the right vehicle for him. He was in a musical at the time, but couldn’t sing well enough for a competition and was told it was a place for comedians, too. Kassir protested he wasn’t really a comedian and was told he could win $100,000 and said, “Fuck…have you seen my act?”
He went on to beat comedians like Rosie O’Donnell and Sinbad before being asked to open for Tom Jones and The Temptations. Kassir threw together a 20-minute act and did a stand-up “trial by fire.” He crafted an act where he played a guy addicted to television. It allowed him to change the channels on himself and utilize the voices he’d been doing since childhood. This led to him landing a role on one of HBO’s first shows, called 1st & Ten.
Our Pun King Was Born
Kassir told us about the audition process for the Crypt Keeper. He was a fan of the EC comics and was sad that his mom gave them to a kid down the street. That gave him a slight edge when up for the role against the likes of Michael Winslow and Charles Fleischer. While both are great comic voices, they wanted to play the character as menacing and scary. Kassir said, “They didn’t get it. This guy is funny. This is the gateway drug to horror. He lets you know this is supposed to be fun. It’s the ride up to the top of the rollercoaster.”
Kassir compared it to Alfred Hitchcock Presents regarding the use of puns. He gave the voice a texture because of the holes in his throat and the rotting teeth. He also added a cackle from his Wicked Witch bit from his abbreviated The Wizard of Oz act. While everyone seemed to love him and told him he had the job, he didn’t believe it. As an actor, he was very aware that things happen and nothing is set in stone. He wasn’t counting on anything until he got the call from his agent.
John Kassir on the Crypt Keeper’s Origins and Future Stars
As a fan and the man behind our beloved icon, Kassir has stories and trivia for days about Tales From the Crypt. The first version of the puppet was made of spare parts that included a pair of leftover Chucky eyes and a mouth that didn’t move. This resulted in the first few episodes having a more toned-down Crypt Keeper. Kassir also let us in on how he would record his voice work after the rest of the episode had been shot. He also pointed out that the show became a training ground for a lot of people who went on to become stars. Actors could not only practice their craft but could also dabble in directing. He lit up as he recounted being asked to come to set to read lines in real time for Arnold Schwarzenegger’s episode.
Tales From the Crypt is the Past and the Future
Kassir spoke about Tales From the Crypt spin-offs and how people didn’t understand how much it was going to mean to the kiddies. However, he did because he remembered discovering the comics as a kid. He pointed out that most of the audience watched it way too young, and that is why we were there. He then took a few questions from the audience and gave us a few more parting puns before posing for a few more pictures for his adoring crowd.
Tales From the Crypt fans with FOMO don’t have to be sad for too long. The entire series is hitting Shudder on May 1st. If people are smart, John Kassir and The Crypt Keeper will be very booked and busy for awhile. So, hopefully, we might all get to hear the infamous cackle live a few more times this spring.


