Reviews
‘Slayers: A Buffyverse Story’ is the Comeback We’ve All Been Waiting For
Buffy the Vampire Slayer may have ended over 20 years ago, but for fans of the show, it’s still something to be discussed at length. Look at the comments on any post about one of Buffy’s boyfriends, and you’re bound to find some intense discussions. Look at the comments on any post any actor from the show does on social media, and you’ll see plenty of folks bringing up the show. Rarely is there an interview with Sarah Michelle Gellar where the show isn’t mentioned.
So, it’s no surprise fans were so excited to learn there was an audio drama being released that brought back many of the original actors from the series. And, as someone who runs a Buffy podcast called Slayerfest98, I’m “fans”.
“I talk about slayers so much the kids at school call me slayer but…in like, a mocking way” –Indira Nunnally
Slayers: A Buffyverse Story had no small task of pleasing die-hard fans of the show while still being accessible to casual and new fans alike. But it achieves all of this thanks to the stellar writing of Amber Benson and Christopher Golden. Golden is known for having written numerous Buffy novelizations back in the day, while Benson is known for playing the beloved, doomed witch Tara Maclay in the series.
After years of rumors about the show returning (it’s not) and comics that are or aren’t canon, we finally have something with the original actors returning that isn’t a Comic Con panel or a reunion photoshoot (all of which are also fun). It doesn’t bring back the titular role. Still, it gets pretty damn close—we get beloved vampire hottie Spike (James Marsters), Sunnydale Queen Bee Cordelia Chase (Charisma Carpenter), surrogate father watcher Rupert Giles (Anthony Stewart Head), everyone’s favorite former vengeance demon Anya (Emma Caulfield-Ford), friendly wrinkly kitten eating demon Clem (James C Leary), unhinged evil vampire Drusilla (Juliet Landau), and lesbian witch Tara Maclay (Amber Benson) all back, alongside some special surprise guests and newcomers, for some top tier vampire slayer antics.
I would be remiss if I mentioned newcomers and didn’t talk about the incredibly charming Laya DeLeon Hayes as newly called slayer, Indira Nunnally.
“Boom, guess what bitches, Indira Nunnally is a slayer now—suck it,” –Indira Nunnally
Indira is both the heart of the series and the voice of the fandom. She’s a fangirl at heart—she recognizes Spike pretty quickly, and their relationship is very reminiscent of the surrogate father relationship the blonde vampire had with Buffy’s little sister, Dawn Summers (Michelle Trachtenberg), on the show. She feels exactly like a slayer we would’ve met on Buffy or Angel—Spike even calls her on said slayer-ness numerous times. She feels fun and fresh, a new slayer that could lead her own spin-off. A slayer for 2023.
The series is set in the present-day Buffyverse and an alternate universe during the present-day Buffyverse, where Buffy never existed. However, Anya, Tara, and Cordelia are all still alive (I guess Cordy should’ve stuck with her wish in season 3’s The Wish). Having these beloved characters back feels like a nice warm hug. They have been allowed to age and grow without fully changing who they are—almost all of them being instantly recognizable the moment they speak (oddly, Giles being the one I didn’t recognize right away). The alt-universe versions of our scoobies also are an interesting take—they’re clearly different but still speak like the characters we know and love. And, I mean, freakin’ Cordelia the Vampire Slayer.
“I’m not the Cordelia you knew” – Cordelia Chase
We all know how Cordelia was turned evil, then put into a coma and brought back for 1 episode on Angel, only to die in such a tragic way that I still cry about it. But crying over your favorite character dying on Buffy or Angel 20+ years later is not that uncommon. I mean, hello Anya, Tara, Jenny Calendar, Fred, Darla, et al. But creating an alternate reality where Cordelia is the chosen one is such a brilliant idea. It feels like a love letter to the fans for allowing this to happen and getting Charisma Carpenter back in the role. This is something that’s made with love and care—something Amber Benson is known for.
It’s not the Cordelia we know, but she still makes comments about her hair, fashion, and has no problem giving a casual read.
“Are you like Spike, Spike? Like Summers, Rosenberg, Giles Spike?” –Indira Nunnally
I’m someone who loves checking in with beloved characters years later. I love getting a little bit of “Where are they now?”. Linda Hamilton coming back as Sarah Connor in the Terminator franchise 20+ years later? Sign me up! Neve Campbell and Courteney Cox coming back to the Scream franchise after 10 years? Heck yes! Jamie Lee Curtis returning to the Halloween franchise? Absolutely!
So it’s nice to see which of our scoobies got their happy endings and which are still fighting the good fight. Spike is, of course, begrudgingly still in the fight—it makes sense that blondie bear wouldn’t be okay just settling down and working a 9 to 5 (although for a vampire, it’d be more like 5 to 9, I guess). And James Marsters, unsurprisingly, doesn’t miss a beat sliding back into the role. He is the series’ main character and sometimes narrator and has never been better. He allows you to, once again, forget he doesn’t actually have a British accent.
The series is a return to form for the Buffyverse and not to be missed. It feels like checking in with an old friend you haven’t seen in years—in the best way possible. The format can be a little jarring if you’ve never listened to an audio drama before (or if you have ADD like me), but it’s so easy to get the hang of it in this pitch-perfect series.
Catch episode-by-episode coverage over on the Slayerfest98 podcast, and be sure to get your copy of Slayers: A Buffyverse Story when it releases on Audible on October 12, 2023!
Reviews
‘The Empty Man’ (2020) Might Be the Best Horror Film of the 21st Century
Not to take you all back to the pandemic, but the scene must be set. If you recall, people were not going to movie theaters in October of 2020. In fact, October might have been the peak of staying indoors during the time. There was not the uncertainty of the first few months of figuring out what to do, and everyone had bunkered down, and things did not begin their ever-so-slight reopening. So, it begs a question: what movies fell under the radar through COVID? Well, in October of 2020, The Empty Man hit theaters.
Even excluding the pandemic of it all, the movie was still done dirty. Its misleading marketing might make you think it’s another run-of-the-mill teen horror. Additionally, a lack of confidence from test screenings led the film to have an extremely limited release, dropped in the middle of COVID. Luckily, the movie has garnered some cult status, but not enough. The Empty Man is a masterpiece. It is a graceful collision of subgenres to form a mind-shattering, nightmare-inducing, terrifying epic of cosmic proportions. The Empty Man is not just underrated. It might be the greatest horror film of this century. Let’s look at why.
The Empty Man’s Opening Scene Is a Horror Masterpiece
Has anyone else noticed a lack of genuine cold opens in horror as of late? Recent hits have had minimal opening credits, and few have an introductory scene to set the stage. It is refreshing to not only have an opening scene that teases the horrors to come, but also stands as its own, functioning as its own short film.
Clocking in at roughly 20 minutes long, this opening is a seemingly disconnected horror story. Taking place in the Himalayas, following a group of hikers stranded in a cabin, it is a complete misdirect. However, it is terrifying. The creature we meet is blood curdling, the isolated setting is terrifying, and the cosmic nature of how unknown all of this is petrifying. Not since the remake of Friday the 13th has there been such an elongated fake-out. It functions on its own outside of the rest of the movie, but also introduces the film’s epic scale. Speaking of scale…
How The Empty Man Blends Cosmic Horror With Multiple Subgenres
The scale of The Empty Man is unlike any horror movie…well, ever! There are examples of genre films akin to it that reach its massive scope, but very rarely does a full-on, capital-H, HORROR film reach these parameters. Both in its twisting story, length, and scale, the film feels tome-like.
The movie plays with about seventeen different subgenres. It starts as an adventure creature-feature then proceeds on from its cold open into what seems to be a teen curse horror. From there, it becomes investigative, eventually having chapters of cult, cosmic, and, ultimately, psychological horror.
A Remarkable Mind-Bending Twist
What is additionally insane about all of this is how wide-scale the film is until its final twist. No spoilers will be shared here about said twist, but it is absolutely brain-breaking. It restructures the entire film, and reframes this Universe-sized story to existentially connect all to our protagonist. To create an epic is one thing, but to somehow bring it down to this small psyche is breathtaking filmmaking.
Its Cinematography Sets It Apart From Modern Horror
I have discussed to death on this website how much I hate the look of a lot of modern horror. It seems people have forgotten the art of color-grading as a whole. With new thrillers, all audiences can expect are white minimalism or boring beiges. However, The Empty Man is not that at all. The Empty Man has one of the best looks of any modern horror film. It rejects the bland simplicity of modern terror, making every shot feel textured and extremely full. Truly, it is a visual behemoth to behold.
Why The Empty Man Deserves Its Status as a Cult Horror Classic
The Empty Man is overall a celebration of horror. It is proof that horror does not have to try to be “elevated” in order talk about deeper themes, or sacrifice any of these themes for gore, blood, and other genre trimmings. The movie finds its inspiration just as much in the literary works of Arthur Machen as it does the green-tinted hellscapes of Rob Zombie.
If you love any type of horror, The Empty Man is for you. It is a masterpiece of the craft, and should be recognized as such. In fact, it is hard to think of any horror film of the 2020s that reaches the peak of The Empty Man’s masterpiece of a summit.
Reviews
How ‘V/H/S: Viral’ Ruined the V/H/S Franchise
My brain doesn’t do the best with recall, but most of the important events I remember surround horror. I can remember the first time I saw the trailer for V/H/S when I was a freshman in college in 2012. That weekend, I took a trip home. It was one of the rare weekends my mom was away, so I convinced my then-stepdad, now my dad(!), into watching V/H/S. I don’t really remember what he thought, but I was awestruck. V/H/S was a gnarly watch. It felt so different than what was out there at the time. The film was scary, bloody, raunchy, and all-around rude.
Cut to a few months later, and word of a sequel spread like wildfire. How could they creatively top V/H/S? To my surprise, V/H/S/2 surpassed all wants and dreams for what the sequel should be. It was somehow meaner, somehow bloodier, and somehow ruder. Blending my favorite subgenre and format, found footage and anthology, V/H/S became a franchise that I fawned over. Every chance to not talk about V/H/S felt like an opportunity wasted. Simply put, I became annoying.
Why V/H/S: Viral Was Such a Disappointing Sequel
One year after that, it all came crashing down. Coming in at a paltry 81 minutes, V/H/S: Viral couldn’t even live up to its own name. It was abhorrently boring. Made no sense in the context of the franchise’s growing story. Had little to no internal cohesion. And, probably worst of all, was a complete eyesore. This headache-inducing film took the goodwill built up throughout the previous two films and curb stomped it. Frankly, it’s embarrassing to watch.
(Please note that this is not a review/rating of segments within the first three films. I love this franchise, and I’m deciding to be critical of what I think the series’ main flaw is: V/H/S: Viral.)
What exactly happened? After losing that core mumblegore group, presumably to other projects, V/H/S: Viral became a shell of what it once was. That’s not to say there aren’t talented filmmakers involved in Viral (I absolutely love Benson and Moorhead). The real problem with V/H/S: Viral is “Vicious Circles” and the lack of continual worldbuilding. To discuss this, we need to take a step back.
How the Original V/H/S Established the Franchise’s Lore
V/H/S’s framing device, “Tape 56” written by Adam Wingard and Simon Barrett, started to build the lore of these VHS tapes. We don’t know exactly how/why, but something happened to Old Man (Frank Stack) while he watched the tapes. As “Tape 56” continues, we see Frank, who was presumed dead, somehow picking off these intruders one by one. What exactly is causing this, though?
The context clues given provide a few potential ideas and raise some questions. 1) Old Man isn’t dead. 2) The Old Man’s reanimation is a consequence of the intruders watching the tape. 3) What is in the tapes that is causing this? 4) Can these tapes be watched in any order, or does it have to be a specific order? All of this is to say one thing: Adam Wingard and Simon Barrett cared to create an intriguing framing device that allowed for unlimited growth.
How V/H/S/2 Expanded the Haunted VHS Tape Mythology
That brings us to V/H/S/2. “Tape 49”, written and directed by Simon Barrett, acts as this installment’s framing device. It follows Larry (Lawrence Michael Levine) and Ayesha (Kelsy Abbott), two private investigators looking into the potential disappearance of a college student named Kyle (L.C. Holt). After breaking into his house, Larry and Ayesha find Kyle’s treasure trove of virulent VHS tapes. Ayesha watches some of the tapes and becomes violently ill. But it’s more than that. (It should also be noted that there are many pictures of Old Man on Kyle’s mantle.)
The True Lore of V/H/S
Throughout the “Tape 49” interludes, we learn even more about the tapes: how and why they do what they do. “I found a new one,” Kyle says, “It’s third or fourth generation from the quality. Got it from some guy in Little Armenia in a pawn shop. He is definitely not the type of guy you usually see trading with us, but I think he’s somebody who’s worth checking in on again. Most of his collection, I would say, is snuff & CP, but he had at least one that was the real thing.”
Kyle’s first monologue reveals a few things. But most importantly, Kyle teaches us that there is not only a market for these tapes, but that they are also pirated (on some occasions). Given Old Man’s setup, it could be inferred that he copies tapes and (potentially) sells them. We also know that the group of intruders was sent to Old Man’s house for the purpose of stealing a tape. “You’ll know which tape when you see it,” or something like that (sorry, I didn’t write down that quote).
The second monologue from Kyle gives us an ironclad explanation of these tapes. “This tape is the final link for me. I know a lot of you have posted that it only affects you if you play it in the correct sequence. But I’ve been experimenting on (mumbling, incoherent) we’re all just electromagnetic energy. If these analog tapes capture the images of the supernatural, they can affect our cerebral cortex…” This tells us the conceit of V/H/S is, more or less, haunted tapes. What it doesn’t tell us is whether these tapes are haunted by those who have died in them or a deeper, darker malicious entity. But it gives us a jumping-off point.
Why “Vicious Circles” Failed the V/H/S Franchise
And that’s when things really get sour.
Marcel Sarmiento’s “Vicious Circles” framing device is all around embarrassing. Which is a surprise because Deadgirl, which Sarmiento co-directed, is fantastic. And his segment in ABCs of Death, “D is for Dogfight”, is brutal as hell. Not only does “Vicious Circles” fall flat, but it just completely bungles any interesting ideas that the previous two films had set for the overall worldbuilding.
Kevin (Patrick Lawrie), the segment’s lead, is a cardboard character. He’s nothing. His existence is only justified through circumstance. Yeah, let’s follow a dude whose main piece of character development is saying, “fuck you,” to his grandma.
While there are way more issues with V/H/S: Viral than its wraparound segment, it’s hard to really specify just how terrible “Vicious Circles” really is. My biggest issue is, obviously, how they handle the pre-built lore. And the film’s careless attempt at making some kind of metaphor for virality. There’s something completely disingenuous about how Sarmiento, as well as his co-writers T.J. Cimfel and David White, tackle this film’s universe. Tenuous connections to previous V/H/S films can’t even save this vile car crash.
How V/H/S: Viral Abandoned the Franchise’s Worldbuilding
That’s not to say there isn’t a way that they could have transitioned from VHS tapes to internet/viral content by any means. I’m sure there is a fantastic way they could have handled this. But the beyond-milquetoast Kevin and the just-here-for-the-T&A Iris (Emilia Ares) make “Vicious Circles” and Viral as a whole an absolute slog to sit through.
Rather than addressing these issues and trying to self-correct, the V/H/S franchise was dead in the water for over half a decade. But when it came back…it was different. Gone was a connected world where rules were established. V/H/S: Viral was the last of the franchise’s overall connectivity, which is a bummer. I genuinely wish there could be a way for the franchise to self-correct; to right the wrongs of Viral.
Can the V/H/S Franchise Ever Recover From Viral?
Look, I love this franchise. I tune in for every single new release. But I really hate what Viral did to the franchise. V/H/S had made itself slightly interesting again with its year-based entries. And then that was quickly kicked to the side with V/H/S: Beyond (and that film doesn’t even stick to its own stipulations).
All of this doesn’t even go into how the V/H/S franchise has nearly abandoned any sense of a wraparound story. That’s also a conversation for another day. There are segments that I love in each entry, but as a whole, the V/H/S franchise is just too full of itself. And, in my eyes, it’s all the fault of V/H/S: Viral.


