Connect with us

Movies

Ranking the Blair Witch Franchise

Published

on

It’s found footage month here at Horror Press, and we couldn’t just let it go by without honoring what is perhaps the most influential elder statesmovie of the subgenre, 1999’s The Blair Witch Project. One of the most profitable independent movies of all time (it made $248.6 million off its roughly $750,000 budget – that’ll buy you a lot of Tamagotchis), the movie thrived off the back of one of the first and best viral marketing campaigns, in which a large number of people, many of whom probably lied about it later, were convinced that it was assembled from the last footage ever shot by a trio of film students who went missing in the woods outside Burkittsville, Maryland.

The Blair Witch Franchise Ranked

Given its profitability, it’s no surprise that The Blair Witch Project launched a film franchise. Admittedly, it’s a little sparse. You couldn’t start a baseball team with the Blair Witch movies, unlike some other horror franchises I could mention. Regardless, it is a truth universally acknowledged that a franchise in possession of the good fortune to last longer than two entries must be in want of a ranking. So that’s what we’re going to do!

As far as Blair Witch “canon” goes, there is a bunch of multimedia ephemera that we won’t be dealing with here. This includes the video games, the comic books, promotional documentaries beyond the original Curse of the Blair Witch, and the eight-part young adult tie-in novel series (which definitely deserves its own article).


#4 
Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2 (2000)

There has been something of a push recently to reclaim Book of Shadows as a Halloween III-esque aberration that nevertheless has something compelling to offer when considered separately from the franchise proper. Whether or not you agree with that (I personally don’t, but no matter), it is still the least Blair Witch-y of them all, necessitating placement at the bottom of the list.

For one thing, it lacks the found footage element, immediately shattering the reality of the original movie, which was still fresh in the public consciousness in 2000. The “reenactment of true events” line is a cop-out, it would have been cheaper and more effective to have made it found footage style. While Book of Shadows is an excellent time capsule of turn-of-the-millennium genre tropes and Gen X fashions, as well as providing a nostalgic trip back to Burkitsville, its tale of Blair Witch obsessives just kinda hanging out in an abandoned factory while vaguely eerie shit happens to them doesn’t benefit from being anywhere near the franchise it ostensibly continues.

#3 Blair Witch (2016)

You’re Next, and The Guest director Adam Wingard and writer Simon Barrett weren’t necessarily the obvious duo to make a Blair Witch movie. I think their entry, which follows a young man and his friends on the hunt for his missing sister, makes plenty of other not-obvious choices along the way, which is much to its benefit. It perhaps has a few too many ingredients thrown into the pot, but quite a few of them deliver a movie that will more than appease those who complain that not enough of the terror of the original BWP shows up onscreen.

Advertisement

It’s more modern and in-your-face scary, which is a totally valid approach to the material, especially for the aforementioned audience. However, it’s a little difficult to justify the droning score they use to try and highlight spookier moments, something that does take you out of the vérité feel of the thing, try as they might to make it sound like some sort of eerie diegetic haunted forest noise, hoping you won’t notice.

#2 Curse of the Blair Witch (1999)

This promotional documentary, created to emphasize the “reality” of the viral marketing campaign around The Blair Witch Project, is surprisingly effective. It walks a tightrope that many supplemental pieces in multimedia campaigns would tumble right off of in the future, offering material that enhances and deepens the experience of watching the movie without giving the game away or over-explaining anything. It explores the origins of the main characters and posits more possible sources of the Blair Witch myth, without actually committing to any single explanation. It’s also a parade of the kookiest 1990s eyewear you ever did see, which is a benefit in and of itself.

#1 The Blair Witch Project (1999)

Call it a gimmick, if you want. Complain about how “nothing actually happens,” if you want. But there’s something primordially effective about the original Blair Witch Project. Whether or not you approach it with the belief that it’s a real-life document (something that I’m fairly certain hasn’t happened this century), there is something potent and compelling about three totally believable kids getting lost in the woods and having their sense of security slowly crumble around them.

It’s viscerally real, and the stars at its center don’t get enough credit for convincingly portraying real-life people without any sense of cinematic polish or winking to the camera. Sure, it’s not going to deliver if you’re coming to it expecting a scare-a-minute roller coaster ride. But if you sit down with The Blair Witch Project ready to let it ooze revoltingly all over you with its low-fi VHS quality and urgent sense of how fucked up and dangerous the American woods can be, it’s a powerful, unforgettable experience.

Brennan Klein is a millennial who knows way more about 80's slasher movies than he has any right to. He's a former host of the  Attack of the Queerwolf podcast and a current senior movie/TV news writer at Screen Rant. You can also find his full-length movie reviews on Alternate Ending and his personal blog Popcorn Culture. Follow him on Twitter or Letterboxd, if you feel like it.

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Movies

The Best Horror You Can Stream on Shudder in November 2024

Shudder knows the holiday season is hard, so they are coming out of the gates swinging. Who has time to fight with their family when there are days of new creepy content to watch this winter? Whether you are finishing the latest season of The Boulet Brothers’ Dragula, or checking out the five new Shudder Originals and Exclusives, that is just the tip of the iceberg for this beloved streamer. They are adding tons of throwback films, deep cuts, and international horror that I need in front of my eyeballs posthaste. Check out my top five picks below and know there is way more where they come from.

Published

on

Shudder knows the holiday season is hard, so they are coming out of the gates swinging. Who has time to fight with their family when there are days of new creepy content to watch this winter? Whether you are finishing the latest season of The Boulet Brothers’ Dragula, or checking out the five new Shudder Originals and Exclusives, that is just the tip of the iceberg for this beloved streamer. They are adding tons of throwback films, deep cuts, and international horror that I need in front of my eyeballs posthaste. Check out my top five picks below and know there is way more where they come from.

The Best Movies to Stream on Shudder This Month

The Creep Tapes (Shudder Original Series)

The Creep Tapes will continue giving us glimpses into the mind of a serial killer who lures videographers to their doom with the promise of a paid job. Creep is one of the few found-footage franchises that I am obsessed with. Like many people, I had hoped Mark Duplass and Patrick Brice would give us another movie. So, I was pleasantly surprised they decided to make a series instead. Not only will we have the honor of seeing Duplass get weird weekly, but I also recently discovered that Josh Ruben will be in the building for at least one episode. My expectations are through the roof, but I think these weirdos (complimentary) will meet and surpass them.

You can watch The Creep Tapes starting on November 15th. New episodes will stream every Friday until the December 13th season finale.

Advertisement

Doc of Chucky (Shudder Original Film)

This Shudder Original is marketed as the ultimate account of the Child’s Play franchise. It charts the journey from humble beginnings to becoming the world’s most beloved killer doll. I am a Chucky stan account. So, I will run toward any documentary about Charles Lee Ray. However, this one is well-timed because Chucky was recently unjustly canceled after three killer seasons. Shudder is also adding all but the first film in the Child’s Play /Chucky franchise this month to mark the occasion. The streamer also has all three seasons of the show, which was the best horror series of the millennium. So, when we finish watching the documentary, we still have days of Chucky content in one place.

You can watch Doc of Chucky on November 1st.

Rita (Shudder Original Film)

13-year-old Rita flees a neglectful home and lands in a state-run orphanage. Her appearance gives the other girls hope as they believe it is a sign of a prophecy coming true, and they begin to plan their escape from their oppressive environment. This Shudder original is a fantasy film based on a tragic true story of brave orphans whose fight for survival led to a nationwide outcry for justice and reform. I expect to cry a lot while watching Rita. The holiday season is the appropriate time to do that, so the timing is immaculate. I also expect to fall into a research rabbit hole after watching because I am unfamiliar with this story. 

You can watch Rita on November 22nd.

Advertisement

Tokyo Gore Police (2008)

A young woman in a privatized police force searched for her father’s killer while combating mutants. This movie came out in 2008, and I still have not seen it. So, I am grateful Shudder is allowing me to fix this oversight. It feels like Tokyo Gore Police will change my life and become my new personality. I am already rooting for this woman who is about to kick mutant ass in a futuristic Tokyo. Also, the fact that the trailer flags it as inappropriate and forces you to consent to watching it confirms this is about to be a moment. I cannot wait to check it out and stop being left out of the conversations.

You can watch Tokyo Gore Police on November 4th.

Tragedy Girls (2017)

Two death-obsessed teens decide to drum up content for their online show by murdering people and sending their small town into a frenzy. Tragedy Girls is one of the best horror comedies that has ever happened to me. What other movie has Alexandra Shipp, Brianna Hildebrand, Josh Hutcherson, Craig Robinson, Kevin Durand, and Jack Quaid on the cast list? I am still upset the rumored series fell through because I needed more time with the girls. This movie is one of the funniest, coolest, and most delightful slashers I have ever seen. It also holds a special place in my heart because I am forever begging for more Black girl slashers! 

Advertisement

You can watch Tragedy Girls on November 4th.

Shoutout to Shudder for giving us a reason to be thankful this November! I plan to live on the streamer this month and soak up all the deadly fun. If my top five picks are not enough proof that you need to park it on the app, open Shudder and see the horrific wonderland for yourself.

Continue Reading

Movies

The Paranormal Activity Franchise, Ranked

The iconic Paranormal Activity franchise began as a low-budget exploration of the Very Bad Thing that happened to Katie (Katie Featherston) and her asshole boyfriend Micah (Micah Sloat) over the course of a couple nights in their San Diego home, where they are being haunted by a demonic presence. However, after setting the world on fire both in terms of its reputation as a terrifying motion picture and a return on investment, the original 2007 found footage movie quickly expanded into a sprawling franchise that now includes multiple members of Katie’s extended family, more than half a dozen movies of varying quality, and a timeline that even Christopher Nolan would say was too complicated.

Published

on

The iconic Paranormal Activity franchise began as a low-budget exploration of the Very Bad Thing that happened to Katie (Katie Featherston) and her asshole boyfriend Micah (Micah Sloat) over the course of a couple nights in their San Diego home, where they are being haunted by a demonic presence. However, after setting the world on fire both in terms of its reputation as a terrifying motion picture and a return on investment, the original 2007 found footage movie quickly expanded into a sprawling franchise that now includes multiple members of Katie’s extended family, more than half a dozen movies of varying quality, and a timeline that even Christopher Nolan would say was too complicated.

Need a primer on the lore behind the Paranormal Activity franchise? Check out our HORROR 101 article here!

The Entire Paranormal Activity Franchise Ranked

How varying is that quality, you ask? Well I’m glad you spoke up, because I happen to have the ultimate, definitive ranking of the franchise prepared for you right here, so why don’t we take a look…

#7 Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin (2021)

It’s hard enough for an installment to be a six-years-later, direct-to-streaming, continuity-light movie in a deeply interconnected franchise that used to have entries hit theaters like clockwork. Unfortunately, this movie made it even harder on itself by spitting on its own found footage conceit at every turn, haphazardly cutting to different, impossible camera angles and frequently incorporating non-diegetic music that breaks the reality of the franchise at every possible turn.

#6 Paranormal Activity: The Ghost Dimension (2015)

For six years, The Ghost Dimension stood as the purest example of how to misunderstand what to do with the Paranormal Activity franchise before Next of Kin came and ate its lunch. It largely ignores the franchise’s established characters and storylines in favor of nonsensical world-building slathered in a 3D gimmick that doesn’t work even a bit. However, it is set at Christmas, which does give it a little bump over Next of Kin, because one thing that almost every horror fan seems to be hard-wired to appreciate is a movie that can be used as subversive seasonal viewing.

Advertisement

#5 Paranormal Activity 4 (2012)

Paranormal Activity 4 is goofy. The front-and-center use of an XBOX Kinect camera dates the movie something fierce, even more than the installments that are explicit period pieces. While it is the last of the “pure” Paranormal Activity movies, it ultimately suffers from severely diminishing returns and doesn’t seem to have an idea of how to continue the ongoing story of the franchise in a satisfying way, or one that makes all that much sense.

#4 Paranormal Activity 3 (2011)

While this is hardly an issue more than a decade after the fact, Paranormal Activity 3 is a case study in how disappointing a movie can be when all the good parts from the trailer end up on the cutting room floor before the finished product actually hits theaters. This installment is the hardest to objectively rank. The oscillating fan camera provides one of the best scare sequences in the franchise, certainly. However, the fact that the movie has so many conspicuously pulled punches should still count against it, and the finale sets up a narrative throughline that, while promising, never really pans out in a satisfying way in future installments.

#3 Paranormal Activity: The Marked Ones (2014)

The Marked Ones is proof positive that focusing on characters who aren’t related to Katie can indeed work out, if you can actually find something unique to do with them. It has a similar structure to the franchise outing Curse of Chucky, actively eschewing continuity until it reveals that it is very much in continuity, to the delight of many fans. However, with or without the franchise connections, the movie is a jack-in-the-box thrill ride filled with engaging characters that puts a unique spin on the franchise’s core premise and shakes some of the doldrums out of a series that was already showing its age at that point in its run.

#2 Paranormal Activity 2 (2010)

Paranormal Activity 2 is the platonic ideal of a Paranormal Activity sequel. It ups the ante considerably. More people in the house, more cameras, higher stakes (there’s a baby in peril). However, it still takes its time and utilizes the original movie’s patented slow, slow burn, not overindulging the audience with whiz-bang effects. It still primarily lets your imagination fill in the gaps of what’s going on in the lurking shadows of this suburban home.

#1 Paranormal Activity (2007)

Look, there’s a reason this movie made more money than a gym membership office on New Year’s Day. It’s extraordinarily effective at every single thing that it’s doing, from the small stuff, like presenting you with a believable suburban couple, to the big stuff, like setting Ouija boards aflame and chucking bodies through the air as you watch a series of seemingly minor unsettling happenings rip that couple apart before your very eyes. The movie is the ultimate home invasion, not only violating the ways we are supposed to feel safe in our own homes, but causing the very laws of physics, logic, and human behavior that govern that safe space to betray us.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Horror Press Mailing List

Fangoria
Advertisement
Advertisement