Editorials
‘It: Chapter Two’ Deserves Better
People hate It: Chapter Two. Unlike many horror sequels or poorly reviewed releases that gain popularity in time, the film has seemingly gained more notoriety. Maybe it’s the occasionally goofy CGI, the heavy comedy, or just how overstuffed it is, but everyone is really down and out on it. Still, though, I will defend this movie like a member of the Losers Club defending their Ka-Tet (deep-cut King reference for you constant readers).
But why, though? Objectively, the movie can feel overstuffed. The CGI is a little goofy. Well, despite all this, I believe It: Chapter Two captures the pure essence of the book. It captures the heart, the terror, and metaphors about small town America excellently…even better than the first one.
It: Chapter Two Is the Ultimate Stephen King Movie
Listen…I am a simple man. If you have this much pure Stephen King energy in a movie, I am going to love it. Why King fans did not grasp onto this movie, I do not know, because it is probably the most “Stephen King” Stephen King movie ever.
We have the small, Maine town and characters from the book, yes, but also a fantastic cameo from the big man himself. Seriously, this movie is like Avengers: Endgame for constant readers (even though Castle Rock is technically more of a crossover). The movie has the heart, small-town summer feeling, and aesthetics for a King film to the max. Whether that is a positive or negative depends on the viewer, but constant readers can relish in how set the movie is on capturing King’s Americana.
It: Chapter Two Understands the Stephen King Novel
Yes, the movie is sillier than the first installment. It’s technically less proficient and cleaner than its predecessor. Still, this movie just generally captures both the message and energy of the book. Don’t get me wrong, It (2017) is excellent in that it feels like a haunted house walkthrough. There are lots of different entities Pennywise dresses up as to attack. It’s colorful, fun…but it takes a lot of liberties. This is fine, but It: Chapter 2 painstakingly portrays the deeper undercurrents and plot beats of the novel.
The Horror Beneath It: Chapter Two
It has always been a story about the darkness behind America’s suburban facade. Behind all of the killer clown and creature feature/cosmic fun, it is about how America’s past will always linger, and is always darker than any fictional entity. It: Chapter 2 does not shy away from its portrayal of bigotry, or its bigger messages about racism and America’s past. The first one has elements of it, but really, Chapter 2 feels like it peels back the kid’s-on-bikes stuff to get to the nitty-gritty of the story.
Additionally, the movie gets the casting down perfectly. Not saying It did not have some of the best child performances ever, but finding not only worthy adult counterparts, but book-accurate players would have to be an arduous task. Huge shout-out to the casting team for absolutely nailing this.
Bill Skarsgård Makes Pennywise Even Scarier
The whole cast blows this movie out of the water, but Pennywise in this one steals the show. Skarsgard is rarely anything less than excellent, but he gets his true horror laurel here. He plays the role as sinister as possible, landing some humor but never letting it weigh down the fear factor.
He is a force to be reckoned with. When making something like a killer clown movie in contemporary times, you have to be really careful not to make it just straight-up silly. Art the Clown is, of course, pure nightmare-fuel, but when approaching the horror big top, it can unintentionally end up feeling like a mismarketed Goosebumps episode.
This, though, is not a case like that. Pennywise is nightmarish in this. His voice is more sinister, and he reads as a predatory cosmic entity, and not just another slasher villain. Fun and frightening, Pennywise pulls no punches in bringing the horror in Chapter 2.
Editorials
‘Hereditary’ (2018) Is the Most Overrated A24 Horror Movie
Once upon a time it was popular to trash on A24 horror movies. It very much still is, in some circles. The complaints were repeated ad nauseam. The movies were too pretentious and slow-moving. They were mis-advertised as horror by their trailers. And so on. While 2017’s It Comes at Night didn’t beat the allegations, the rest of their horror output deserves more credit. I wanted to lay all this out to explain my background feelings about A24 horror. Because the reason I’m here today is to lay into their 2018 “modern classic” Hereditary. I’m a dyed-in-the-wool hater here. No thoughtless A24 band wagoning for me. Hereditary is overrated.
Yes, Hereditary is Overrated
OK, is “hater” too strong a word? Probably. Here at Horror Press, we love horror. We love horror even when it’s wronging us, in the hopes that it will figure itself out and get better. Plus, the thing that’s perhaps most frustrating to me about Hereditary is how many people love it uncritically. And that’s certainly not Hereditary’s fault.
I totally get where most of the love is coming from, by the way. Ari Aster’s debut film has a lot going for it. For one thing, the fabulous Toni Collette is cranking her performance as grieving mother Annie Graham up to 11. (Then again, Aster exhausts me by asking her to pitch herself at that level practically the entire time.)
But all the leads are good, actually. Alex Wolff is transcendent as a compellingly tortured teenager, and Milly Shapiro is the perfect blend of innocent and creepy. Plus, that allergic reaction scene is gnarly. (Even though anyone who’s known a kid with severe allergies recognizes that the setup for that sequence makes no sense.)
Why Hereditary’s Story Falls Apart After Its Shocking First Act
Unfortunately, there’s much more to discuss on top of those parenthetical complaints that mar the strongest elements. Including the fact that Hereditary is frontloaded with all its best and freshest material. There is so much specificity to the characters and their situation in the beginning. It all flies out the window after the allergic reaction scene. Everything that follows is some flavor of generic horror trope.
Hereditary’s Themes of Mental Illness and Grief Don’t Deliver
This includes the much-ballyhooed throughline about Annie being concerned she may have inherited a mental illness from her late mother. It tries to glom onto the eerie “is this all in her head?” trope but fails constantly. Its desire to shove horror imagery down our throats makes the attempts at ambiguity feel frustratingly pointless. Frankly, Aster should have abandoned the ambiguity from square one. He could’ve made more effort into making that imagery more unique.
Sure, you’d have to rename the movie if you did that. But this throughline is one of the least satisfying elements of the entire movie. So maybe it shouldn’t have been called Hereditary in the first place.
Does Hereditary’s Ending Borrow Too Much From Paranormal Activity 4?
Also, it’s wild how Hereditary managed to get away with cribbing the majority of Act 3 from Paranormal Activity 4. With all due respect to everyone behind it (who’ve all got superb movies on their filmographies), PA4’s a hot mess. It’s the last of the Paranormal Activity movies anyone should think to borrow from. For those who don’t remember, it’s the one with the Xbox Kinect.
But Hereditary borrows everything for its final moments. Including implying a broader supernatural world of witchery that would have been more interesting to follow from the jump.
Horror Movies That Explore Hereditary’s Ideas Better
At least for me, all of these issues make watching Hereditary a total slog. What makes it even more frustrating is that there are plenty of movies that do what it does, but better. Some of these came out after the fact, making this a mounting issue over time. But even in 2018, watching Hereditary felt like listening to a Kidz Bop version of a favorite song.
If you want Toni Collette as an iconic horror movie mother, look no further than The Sixth Sense. If you love Aster’s no-holds-barred (or “inelegant,” if you’re nasty) approach to emotion, his solid follow-up Midsommar has your back. If you want more compelling horror movies about grief, check out The Night House or The Babadook. If you want a teeth-grinding dinner table scene, check out You’re Next. Check out The Changeling’s séance. Talk to Me’s facial mutilation of a minor. Rosemary’s Baby’s creepy coven of modern witches.
Why Hereditary Remains One of Horror’s Most Overrated Movies
I shall close this out with a reminder that it’s OK to like, or even love, Hereditary. Nothing I say or feel can take that away from you. But I’m hoping to communicate why I was frustrated by the reaction that it got at the time. Followed by the glowing reputation that it has continued to enjoy since its debut. Hopefully by communicating that frustration, I can make others who are in my boat feel less alone. And then we can all go watch The Sixth Sense together and forget our troubles.
Editorials
Is the ‘Friday the 13th’ Franchise Overrated?
There’s pretty much a slasher for every season if you’re a horror fan. Michael Myers staked his claim on Halloween in 1978. Billy Chapman slays the winter with boughs of holly, or maybe you watch the other Billy conjured up by Bob Clark in Black Christmas. But when summer rolls around, there’s really only one guy on your mind. As Casey Becker might put it: He’s big, he doesn’t play football, but he’ll kick your ass! Despite the hockey mask, he doesn’t even play that sport. Jason Voorhees is just a menacing spirit waiting at the bottom of the lake for his next jolt of life.
I grew up on slashers. First, I was deathly afraid of them, running past the kitchen island thinking Chucky was waiting for me. I eventually found comfort in them no matter how ridiculous the plot lines were getting. Halloween (1978) and Michael Myers were my pick of the litter. But he never went to space like Jason. Despite the absurdity and evolving villain design, Friday the 13th just never curbed my appetite. There are individual entries to the franchise that are rewatchable for me. But as a whole, this franchise is just boring.
Why the Friday the 13th Franchise Is Overrated
Do I feel like a weight has been lifted off of me for finally speaking my truth? Absolutely. Do I also feel like a hate train is forming against me now? Also yes. But the truth of the matter is the Friday the 13th franchise is a clear indicator of the slasher boom in the worst way. The first entry was compelling with how it’s plotted. Admittedly, I watched it after Jason was already the icon of its legacy. Pamela Voorhees’ reveal in the end definitely gagged the audience in 1980. You can tell they had no intention of serializing the concept, though. Victor Miller, the screenwriter for the first film, certainly wasn’t happy that Jason was exploited as the villain in the sequels to follow. He explained, “He is just a stock villain and I don’t have much sympathy for him.”.
How Jason Voorhees Became a Slasher Movie Icon
The transmogrification of Jason, from victim to villain, was where the money resided. Audiences wanted their next Michael Myers. Especially after John Carpenter killed off his own icon to spite the studio heads. Friday the 13th Part 2 (1981) was supposed to be an anthological entry. Its predecessor’s success shifted the focus back to the camp where Jason lurked in the woods for revenge. I watched this most recently in a full rewatch of the whole franchise and I still can’t tell you what happens. It’s just not memorable. Neither in Part 3 (1982) with the exception of how it introduces the hockey mask into the franchise. Maybe I’d feel differently if I experienced it in 3D.
Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter and the Problem With Endless Sequels
The Final Chapter (1984) is where my interest begins to pique with Corey Feldman playing a young brother obsessed with making masks. Intended to be the conclusion of the franchise, it actually introduces one of the earliest examples of a final boy. I’d say that’s a big reason for its strong performance in the box office. So strong that the studio heads said, “Well, I guess we HAVE to make another now.” Are you sensing the same pattern I am? It smells a lot like capitalism and consumerism.
Jason Lives and the Missing Summer Camp Horror
Even in the four entries of Friday the 13th, Tommy Jarvis (played by Corey Feldman) is the only child we’ve seen in one of these movies. I do like Friday the 13th: A New Beginning (1985) despite the usual stigmatized depictions of mental health. Let’s not forget, though, we’re here for a summer camp slasher. Where are the kids at camp? Camp kids finally make an appearance by Friday the 13th Part VI: Jason Lives (1986). I’ll watch this installment and wish that this was the film that we had all along. At this point, he’s officially a member of the undead with superhuman strength. It’s the entry that sparked the beginning of the franchise’s absurdity, and it doesn’t end until 2003 when Freddy Krueger wakes him from his slumber.
Halloween vs. Friday the 13th: Which Slasher Franchise Holds Up Better?
On paper, a franchise like Friday the 13th and Halloween are essentially the same when it comes to consistency. They both lack it. But for me, Halloween’s consistent tone makes it a much more sustainable franchise to revisit. It always comes back to Laurie Strode and it never goes to space. Despite timeline erasures and the introduction of cult influences, any entry can be the Halloween movie you need for the season. I can’t, and won’t, say the same for Friday the 13th as a summer camp slasher. When summer rolls back around, I’ll be turning on Sleepaway Camp (1983) instead.


